FLC | USFS-funded UNH research finds pandemic impacts added stress to national forests

USFS-funded UNH research finds pandemic impacts added stress to national forests

April 27, 2022

Many human experiences were uniquely altered during the COVID-19 pandemic including a significant rise in the number of people seeking outdoor recreation options during quarantine. In a series of studies funded by the U.S. Forest Service (USFS), researchers at the University of New Hampshire (UNH) found a dramatic increase during the pandemic of visitors to the parks and protected areas of New England that resulted in significant social, situational and ecological impacts on people’s behavior, decision making and experience quality.

“At the height of the pandemic, in the summer of 2020, outdoor recreation visitation within New England national forests increased by more than 60%, or approximately two million visitors, a majority of which came from out of state,” said Michael Ferguson, assistant professor of recreation management and policy at UNH. “While it was great to see so many people rediscovering the outdoors and taking advantage of recreation opportunities, it also raised questions and concerns about these already overwhelmed natural resources.”

The extensive suite of research, which includes a study published March 30 in the journal Society and Natural Resources, assesses the status of the so-called outdoor renaissance at the peak of the pandemic by examining visitation increases and shifts in behavior and decision making at the White Mountain National Forest and the Green Mountain National Forest. While the pandemic fueled visitation issues, these national forests were already seeing significant problems as early as 2017, including social (crowding and conflict), situational (site access and litter) and ecological (snowpack and ticks).

During the summer of 2020, resource managers at the White Mountain National Forest commissioned the researchers to take a closer look at these concerns; they found never-before-seen visitation numbers resulting in even more pervasive recreation challenges including long traffic lines, lack of parking, trail congestion and unprecedented instances of overcrowding and discord.

The researchers found that for the most part, visitors were largely able to cope and deal with most of the situations they encountered, but the one factor that was consistently difficult for them to tolerate was visitor conflict. This included arguments or disagreements, mostly between in-state and out-of-state visitors, largely based on perceived violations of pandemic safety protocols like not wearing masks or honoring physical distancing.

“Our data and modeling suggest that approximately 10% of annual visitation, which represents nearly 400,000 visitors, noted they would likely never return for outdoor recreation because of the issues they experienced,” Ferguson said.

To validate these initial findings, the researchers took a deeper dive into the impact of the pandemic on outdoor recreation visitors, with a specific focus on historically marginalized populations. This paper, published in February by the Journal of Outdoor Recreation and Tourism, confirmed the huge surge in national forest visitation during the pandemic and explored the significant increase in adverse interactions. The researchers also found that historically marginalized populations stated unique hurdles. For instance, low income visitors reported significantly less substitution options as opposed to high income visitors and female visitors reported significantly higher instances of conflict during the pandemic.

“COVID-19 unleashed a phenomenon that we didn’t anticipate,” Ferguson said. “It really changed the outdoor recreation experience and the manner in which these resources and experiences must be managed.”

The UNH findings add to the body of USFS-funded research suggesting that the COVID-19 pandemic changed public outdoor recreation patterns in impactful ways. In a study published in January by PLOS One, researchers from the USFS and Colorado State University found similar pandemic effects on federal campground use.

Researchers say more studies are needed to determine next steps but hope this extensive research will help pinpoint continued issues and improve the decision-making process for resource managers, elected officials and visitors. The study team also noted that many parks and protected areas across the country experienced similar issues and moved to managed access systems to combat increasing visitation. Researchers are hopeful that future studies will help determine the best solutions for the New England national forest system.

Read the Society & Natural Resources study: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/08941920.2022.2055247?journa...

Read the Journal of Outdoor Recreation and Tourism study: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2213078022000135